Cruxlux
New here? Jump in... X
Click the links below any post to see top , , and to it.
Boost posts you think are good. This will increase their scores and help them move up. Boost
Click beneath any post to join the debate on it yourself and shed more light.
Spread the word and invite friends or groups—to get support, to challenge and convince, or just to share.
Live: Conversation about this topic
Invite someone to this debate by username, group, or email address:
Assertion:
Brett Favre should retire

Cruxes...
Insufficient information so far. Help explore this issue by adding responses (either in support or against).

Points

1
Boost
Report

May 18 2007

nobody2 avatar

nobody2

Communities

Default Avatar Default Avatar Default Avatar

Sites


Support 1
Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody2 avatar nobody2

Default Avatar Default Avatar
Expand
His poor play hurts his team

Counterarguments
Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody3 avatar nobody3

Default Avatar
Point
The team clearly disagrees, wouldn't bring him back otherwise

Support 2
Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody1 avatar nobody1

Default Avatar Default Avatar
Expand
he's ruining his legacy

Counterarguments
Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody1 avatar nobody1

Default Avatar Default Avatar
Point
Nothing can erase his accomplishments

Support 3
Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody1 avatar nobody1

Default Avatar Default Avatar
Expand
He shouldn't risk further injury

Counterarguments
Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody3 avatar nobody3

Default Avatar
Point
He's a football player and can make the call himself

Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody2 avatar nobody2

Default Avatar Default Avatar
Point
He has been relatively injury free through his career. He's tough.

A fresh support (Boost this post if you think it is a good argument, even if you don't agree with it.)
Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody1 avatar nobody1

Default Avatar Default Avatar
Expand
Should give his young, talented backup (Rogers) a chance

Counterarguments
Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody2 avatar nobody2

Default Avatar Default Avatar
Point
Rogers is getting a chance to learn from a master

Boost
Magnify Report
1

May 18

2007

nobody2 avatar nobody2

Default Avatar Default Avatar
Point
No evidence that Rogers can do any better

Representation

Represented Sites:

Represented Communities:

Default Avatar Default Avatar Default Avatar Default Avatar Default Avatar Default Avatar Default Avatar Default Avatar
Challenged / Invited

Invite more people/groups using the field at the top of this page.

Share
and/or
Del.icio.us Digg Share on Facebook Reddit Slashdot StumbleUpon
Context
< We're here now:
Brett Favre should retire
Recent Activity
A football player is not qualified to make m... [debate]
He hasn't had a chance to provide evidence [debate]
No man is above the team [debate]